Last Updated: February 26, 2019
Celia Miller Author: Celia Miller

Best Pooper Scooper for Dogs

Best Pooper Scooper for Dogs

The reality of owning a dog is that they poop a lot, with the average dog going multiple times a day. Most dog owners can agree that one of the more unpleasant tasks of caring for your four-legged family member is picking up this waste and disposing of it. Not doing so could potentially be breaking the law, particularly if you don’t own your own land or dog run. Dog waste can carry diseases and is one of the main sources of contamination for natural water sources such as lakes and streams. If your dog has free run of your property or yard then you know it can be a lot of work to pick up all the land mines before the lawn mower or your shoe does! A good pooper scooper can make this task fast and easy.

Choose a charity on Amazon Smile on Spots.com then purchase
via links on this page to donate a portion
of your purchase. Learn more »
Nomad Pets Tidy Turd Pooper Scooper Set
Nomad Pets  Tidy Turd Pooper Scooper Set
$0
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
3/10
  • What we Like
  • Can be used with or without bags
  • Comes with 20 bags
  • Lightweight
  • What we Dislike
  • Squeeze mechanism requires strong grip
  • Plastic handle holding top and bottom components may break
  • Bags require rubber band to hold in place
  • Cheaper construction
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Jaw-style
MATERIAL Plastic
SIZE 24" long
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

This is a decent enough scooper for light duty or level grass but will not work well in deeper grass, rocks, or other vegetation. The springs may pop off. The bags are thin and require a rubber band to stay in place, which the seller generously includes with the purchase. If used without the bags, this scooper will be difficult to clean.

OUT! Dog Poop Scoop and Rake + Refill Bags
OUT! Dog Poop Scoop and Rake + Refill Bags
$0
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
3/10
  • What we Like
  • Large bin
  • Rake also has smooth side for scooping or raking dog waste
  • What we Dislike
  • Handle is flimsy and weak with 3 joints that come loose
  • Inside lip on bucket makes loading difficult
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Rake-and-bin style
MATERIAL Plastic
SIZE Extends up to 33"
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

In theory, this design is effective and versatile, ideal for multiple kinds of landscaping. Unfortunately, it’s all cheap plastic that wears out quickly and the screw-together handle on the bucket and rake are weak points. We like the idea of the rake functioning as either a rake or a scoop but it’s a little flimsy and can be frustrating if the dog waste rolls from one side of the rake to another. The bucket has a lip inside to hold dog waste in but makes it difficult to load the bucket and requires a little more effort to deposit the dog waste during scooping.

Petmate 71034 Arm & Hammer Swivel Bin & Rake Pooper Scooper
Petmate 71034 Arm & Hammer Swivel Bin & Rake Pooper Scooper
$30
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
1/10
  • What we Like
  • Pivoting bucket handle
  • Use with or without plastic bags
  • Handle can be shortened or lengthened
  • Waste bags included, secured with hooks
  • What we Dislike
  • Snap-together joints on handles can untwist and weaken over time
  • Flimsy construction
  • Does not hold up well with rugged or rocky surfaces
  • Bin is very small
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Rake-and-bin style
MATERIAL Plastic
SIZE Extends up to 32"
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

This product would be adequate for smaller dog breeds and smaller piles of dog waste but will not hold up well to excessive use. Its weakness is the plastic material in its construction. The handles easily become unscrewed and so does the rake at the bottom, and this can become most inconvenient while you are in the middle of scooping. We do like that this product can be used with plastic shopping bags because the manufacturer’s scented bags are stinky and expensive.

Spotty Metal Tray with Rake
Spotty Metal Tray with Rake
$0
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
5/10
  • What we Like
  • Lightweight construction
  • Two handles snap together for storage
  • Sturdy handle
  • What we Dislike
  • Very small tray
  • Aluminum bends easily
  • For smaller dogs only
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Rake-and-bin style
MATERIAL Wood
aluminum
SIZE 36.75
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

This is a functional design. The bin has a flat straight edge making it easier to collect dog waste. Unfortunately, you sacrifice durability for the lightweight construction. The handle is sturdy, but the aluminum bin and rake and the hardware used is all rather flimsy. The bin is 6.5″ wide, 6.5″ deep so it may not hold very much if you are on poop patrol cleaning multiple dog messes.

Nature's Miracle Non-Stick Advanced Jaw Scoop
Nature's Miracle Non-Stick Advanced Jaw Scoop
$0
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
4/10
  • What we Like
  • Lightweight
  • Antimicrobial plastic
  • What we Dislike
  • Springs are weak
  • Jaws may not work in taller grass or rocks
  • Plastic construction can be brittle and break
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Jaw style
MATERIAL Plastic
metal
SIZE medium (27" high)
jumbo (32" high)
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

This is a standard design for a jaw-style scooper with a decent-sized scoop allowing multiple pick-ups and a decent handle with a good length.  Unfortunately, the plastic materials in its construction are its weak points.  It does not hold up well over time, especially if left outdoors or in cooler weather. The squeezing mechanism on the handle may be difficult for some users to grip. The springs on it are cheap and break easily. For the price, we’d like to see better materials.

Precision Pet by Petmate Little Stinker Heavy Duty Pooper Scoop
Precision Pet by Petmate Little Stinker Heavy Duty Pooper Scoop
$0
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
4/10
  • What we Like
  • Powder-coated steel for easy cleaning
  • Hooks and nested design for easy storage
  • Telescoping handles
  • What we Dislike
  • Welded joints for bin can weaken
  • Weak telescoping joints in handle can break
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Rake-and-bin style
MATERIAL Plastic
steel
SIZE up to 44"
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

The metal used in this rake-and-bin style scooper is excellent and we love that it’s sturdy but there are design flaws such as weak welds holding the bin to the handle and cheap locking mechanisms on the telescoping handle. Unfortunately the bin often just snaps completely off as the loop that holds the handle in place is not affixed in place with bolts or screws, just a weak weld. The powder coating makes the metal rust resistant but unfortunately, the texture is difficult to clean when there is dried dog waste buildup on it.

Flexrake Standard Poop Pet Scoop/Spade with 3-Feet Aluminum Handle
Flexrake Standard Poop Pet Scoop/Spade with 3-Feet Aluminum Handle
$25
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
6/10
  • What we Like
  • All-aluminum construction
  • Non-slip vinyl grips
  • What we Dislike
  • May need additional screws to hold together
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Rake-and-bin style
MATERIAL Aluminum and vinyl
SIZE 36"
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

We like the all-metal construction of this scooper and the generous size of the bin for collecting dog waste. The handle is longer than most, making this easier to use. The metal bin and spade are easy to keep clean. The riveted look is actually just punched/stamped metal holding the two components together rather than being bolted or screwed in place so the bin may pop off the handle. A drilled hole and a few extra pieces of hardware are recommended to reinforce it.

Dogit Jawz Waste Scoop
Dogit Jawz Waste Scoop
$12
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
5/10
  • What we Like
  • Jaw style comes in either street or grass option
  • Contoured rubber grip
  • Can be used with plastic bags or by itself
  • What we Dislike
  • Plastic can become brittle and snap
  • Springs are weak
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Jaw style
MATERIAL Plastic
SIZE 25.5"
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

We like that this scooper comes with two jaw variations- grass and street. The jaws will hold several piles of dog waste before needing to be emptied.  This design suffers from many of the same flaws other jaw-style scoopers do with weak springs and a strong grip required to work the mechanism that opens and closes the jaws. Light use may not pose a problem but this one will not hold up well in extreme temperatures or with heavy usage.

Mr. Peanut's 27" Pooper Scooper Pack
Mr. Peanut's 27
$0
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
3/10
  • What we Like
  • Non-slip grip handle
  • Includes 12 rolls of poop bags
  • ABS plastic
  • What we Dislike
  • Flimsy plastic construction
  • Weak springs
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Jaw style
MATERIAL Plastic
SIZE 27"
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

his plastic jaw-style pooper scooper is constructed of flimsy plastic materials and will not hold up well over time, especially if left outdoors or in cooler weather. The mechanism on the handle may be difficult for some users to grip to open the plastic jaws. The springs on it are cheap and break easily. We weren’t terribly impressed with the quality of the bags included either, they tear easily.

Best Rake-and-Bin Style
Yangbaga Metal Pet Poop Tray and Rake
Yangbaga Metal Pet Poop Tray and Rake Best Rake-and-Bin Style
$0
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
9/10
  • What we Like
  • Stainless steel
  • Bin stands upright on its own
  • Easy to clean
  • What we Dislike
  • May be difficult to scrub clean due to texture
  • Plastic handle joints may weaken
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Rake-and-bin style
MATERIAL Metal and plastic
SIZE Rake (27.8")
Spade (31")
Bin (38")
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

This is a great 3-piece rake-and-bin set made of good materials. We absolutely love that this comes with both a spade and rake. Not all poop-scooping scenarios will work with a rake or a spade and it’s nice to have both on hand. These handles go together easily but have plastic joints which may weaken over time. The steel is sturdy and solid and the rivets holding everything together are nice. Versatile, easy to use, and with handles long enough to actually spare you from having to stoop to the ground each time you need to clean up waste, this is an outstanding value.

Newbo Pooper Scooper with 40 Black Poop Bags
Newbo Pooper Scooper with 40 Black Poop Bags
$0
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
3/10
  • What we Like
  • Includes scooper, carabiner and bags
  • ABS material
  • Compact
  • What we Dislike
  • Requires stooping down
  • Should not be used without bags
  • Best for small dog messes
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Jaw-style
MATERIAL Plastic
SIZE 9.8" x 4.3" x 3"
COLOR CHOICES 4
Our Review

This is a good design for a user who may not mind scooping down to clean up one or two messes. You will need to use a sturdy bag every time otherwise clean-up could be very unpleasant. The spring mechanism opens the jaws vs. closing them and the springs are usually some of the first components to go in jaw-style pooper scoopers. The plastic is sturdy. This is not ideal for larger dogs and their bigger messes.

Doody Digger Pooper Scooper
Doody Digger Pooper Scooper
$0
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
1/10
  • What we Like
  • Made in the US
  • No moving parts
  • Can be used with any bags
  • What we Dislike
  • Tube can become clogged very easily
  • Difficult to clean
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Alternative
MATERIAL High-density polyethylene
SIZE 45"
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

We really wanted to like this design and for some dog owners it may be a good solution. We just don’t like the idea of a tube getting full of messy dog waste and how difficult it may be to clean it if the waste traveling through it was too soft to make it to the attached bag. You’ll spend time having to clean it after every use. This could be really smelly in a warmer climate. The idea of the bag coming loose during the process of shaking the dog waste through the tube and into the bag is a horrifying one.

Best Jaw Style
Pik-a-poo 7 One-Handed Pooper Scooper
Pik-a-poo 7 One-Handed Pooper Scooper Best Jaw Style
$25
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
6/10
  • What we Like
  • Ergonomic trigger grip
  • Nylon
  • Adjustable scoop head
  • Flashlight
  • What we Dislike
  • Cannot be used without bags
  • May not work with multiple pick-ups
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Jaw-style
MATERIAL Plastic
nylon
aluminum
SIZE medium (28" high)
large (31" high)
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

We love all the thoughtful features built into this jaw-style pooper scooper such as the trigger-style mechanism (requires less squeezing than the big grip style scoopers), the onboard poop bag storage and a flashlight. The teeth on the jaws are longer but once you have the bag in place you will still have similar issues that scoopers with short teeth have when scooping in taller grass or rough surfaces like gravel. You will have to use a bag with this scooper or dog waste will fall out of the jaws so it’s not as environmentally friendly.

GoGo Stik, The Totally Clean Pooper Scooper
GoGo Stik, The Totally Clean Pooper Scooper
$30
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
7/10
  • What we Like
  • Can be used with grocery bags
  • Long handle
  • Optional set includes scoop with handle
  • Ergonomic grips
  • What we Dislike
  • Plastic blade can break especially on paved or rough surfaces
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Rake-and-bin style
MATERIAL Plastic
SIZE medium (25"-36")
large (37")
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

This rake-and-bin style scooper is basically a circular loop or blade with a bag looped around it to catch dog waste as it passes through the loop. We recommend getting the Clean Scoop set version of this scooper (includes a spade) as it can be difficult to get poop into the bag without something to guide it in with. This is an excellent product to hold under your dog while he is squatting if you can train him to allow it. The handles are comfortable to grip but the telescoping handle may weaken over time.

Just Run Biodegradable Dog Poop Bags
Just Run Biodegradable Dog Poop Bags
$25
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
7/10
  • What we Like
  • Completely biodegradable
  • Leak-proof
  • What we Dislike
  • Assembly required for each pick-up
  • Not for larger dog messes
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Rake-and-bin style
MATERIAL Paper
bamboo
SIZE 6.5" x 8.8"
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

These are basically a recycled paper barf bag with chopsticks that hold it open like a tent while you use a cardboard cone to push the dog waste into the bag which could hold about half of an 18 oz bottle of water. For travel, short trips, walks, smaller dogs, smaller messes and fewer clean-ups these could be an environmentally friendly solution but we don’t think they’re practical for around the yard or property. We’re not terribly fond of assembly-required poop-scooping each and every time.

Four Paws Dog Rake Pooper Scooper
Four Paws Dog Rake Pooper Scooper
$0
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
2/10
  • What we Like
  • Metal bin and rake
  • What we Dislike
  • Weak handles
  • Flimsy aluminum
  • Wood composite product
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Rake-and-bin/ jaw style hybrid
MATERIAL Wood
aluminum
SIZE 33.5" high
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

This design works in theory only but is extremely difficult to use unless you are cleaning up dog waste under only the most optimal conditions. It has serious quality control issues and due to the flimsy materials used breaks easily. Rake and bin do not line up consistently, and due to the scissor-like attachment, it’s difficult to maneuver when trying to pick up a larger dog pile.

Best for Joggers
DogBuddy New Pooper Scooper
DogBuddy New Pooper Scooper Best for Joggers
$19
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
8/10
  • What we Like
  • Integrated waste bag compartment
  • Expandable compartment
  • Clips on leash
  • What we Dislike
  • Better for smaller to medium sized dogs
  • Bags required for use
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Jaw style
MATERIAL Plastic
SIZE small (5.3" x 4.1")
medium (5.9" x 4.8")
large (7.1" x 5.9")
COLOR CHOICES 3
Our Review

This jaw-style scooper is basically an extension of your hand. You cover it with the bag and scoop the dog waste into the reservoir which expands. As long as it doesn’t get dirty this is a great solution because it is small and compact and can be hooked on the dog’s leash or harness for walks. It’s probably not very practical for larger scale poop patrol but for walks and travel it’s a great solution.

Bully Tools 92730 14-gauge 4-Inch Box Style Trench Shovel
Bully Tools 92730 14-gauge 4-Inch Box Style Trench Shovel
$0
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
9/10
  • What we Like
  • Commercial grade 14 gauge steel
  • Welded construction
  • Fiberglass handle
  • Closed back
  • What we Dislike
  • Heavy
  • May tear up grass or sod
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Rake-and-bin style
MATERIAL Steel and fiberglass
SIZE medium (4")
large (6")
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

When it comes to scooping dog waste sometimes the best solutions are the simplest ones. We love trenching shovels for the easy angle, sharp blade and deep bins for holding big dog messes. This one is great because the angle is ideal for scooping and dumping dog waste into a receptacle. No plastic bags needed. The most environmentally friendly way to dispose of dog waste is to throw it in the trash in a bigger bag that will break down rather than hundreds of tiny little bags.

Best Budget
True Temper Forged Round Point Shovel
True Temper Forged Round Point Shovel Best Budget
$40
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
8/10
  • What we Like
  • Cushion end grip
  • Hardwood handle
  • Deep rounded area for waste
  • Pointed tip allows for more precise scooping
  • What we Dislike
  • May still need rake for difficult messes
  • Heavy
  • May tear up grass or sod
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Rake-and-bin style
MATERIAL Forged steel
fiberglass
SIZE 45" handle
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

Another environmentally friendly alternative to the plastic bags and solutions that break, the classic garden shovel is always a great option for clearing your dog’s land mines from a yard or property quickly when coupled with a good sturdy waste bin. These shovels can sit out in all weather and do not require assembly or extensive set-up.They are a little heavier than the cheaper aluminum and plastic options but will likely be around for years to come.

Best Overall
Jibber Gear The Natural - Extra Long 48" Handle
Jibber Gear The Natural - Extra Long 48 Best Overall
$34
Review manufacturer amazon
on amazon
9/10
  • What we Like
  • Works for most surfaces
  • Also ideal for other animal waste
  • No poop bags needed
  • Made in the USA
  • What we Dislike
  • Will need to be treated for rust resistance
  • Must lift tines upwards to keep waste from rolling back out
  • Not suitable for use in snow or ice
Product Details
TYPE OF SCOOPER Rake-and-bin
MATERIAL Wood
steel
SIZE 48" handle
tines are 3/8" apart
COLOR CHOICES 1
Our Review

This is an old-fashioned handmade tool that is ideal for combing through grass to pick up every last bit of dog waste. We love the design and the long handle but do wish it were stained or finished a little differently. We would probably wrap the handle. The tines are welded on, are solid and hold up well. You cannot pick up multiple piles at once with it as the forked head is 6″ across but it does help with picking up the smaller, looser waste.

Best Products Best Pooper Scooper for Dogs
Product Name Best for Rate
Yangbaga Metal Pet Poop Tray and Rake Best Rake-and-Bin Style 9
Pik-a-poo 7 One-Handed Pooper Scooper Best Jaw Style 6
DogBuddy New Pooper Scooper Best for Joggers 8
True Temper Forged Round Point Shovel Best Budget 8
Jibber Gear The Natural - Extra Long 48" Handle Best Overall 9

HOW TO CHOOSE A POOPER SCOOPER:

Consider where and how often you will be using this tool. Do you need something compact you can take on a walk or to the dog park or is this a tool you’ll primarily be using on your own property, where portability is not a concern? Do you need a scooper that will make it easy to clean up waste without bending down or would one of the models without a long handle work for you? Some dog owners are unable to reach the ground easily due to injury or other condition and therefore a longer handle will make it easier to scoop. Some of the jaw-style scoopers require gripping a handle or trigger to open and close the scooper and this may prove difficult for those with a limited range of motion or strength in their hands.

The cost and environmental impact of your clean-up method and materials are also considerations when choosing a good scooper. Many of the models on the market rely on the use of plastic bags to avoid contact with dog waste. Unfortunately many of these will necessitate a bag for each pile of waste being scooped. The best scoopers that rely on bags for waste collection will allow multiple uses.

We’ve narrowed our reviews into two categories for the best pooper scoopers:

Rake & Bin style: Two-piece scooper usually including a bin/tray and rake/shovel component

  • Not as portable
  • Better for cleaning up more than one pile
  • Not as destructive to grass and landscaping

Jaw-style: A one-piece scooper usually comprised of two hinged pieces that scoop waste

  • Typically more portable than two-piece scoopers
  • Often rely on the use of bags to keep waste out of hinge mechanisms
  • May be more difficult to clean

While a pooper scooper can eliminate the need to use a bag to pick up poop with your hand, it’s important to remember that most scoopers will still need to be cleaned particularly if they malfunction or jam. The appeal for many of using pooper scoopers is that you will not use as many plastic bags, which are not always an environmentally friendly choice. However, for occasions where you would use a single bag anyway on walks or at the dog park, a scooper that relies on the use of bags merely makes it possible for you to scoop dog waste without using your hand but will not cut down on the use of bags. A rake-and-bin style scooper can be used to clean up multiple messes with one bag or without one altogether.

Rake-and-bin style scoopers may not be as portable or lightweight as the jaw-style scoopers but they are often more durable, often made with steel and wood handles, resembling garden tools. These also tend to be easier on your landscape as you have more control over how much turf or grass is being scooped up along with the dog waste.