Best Indestructible Dog Toy

Best Indestructible Dog Toy
Profile photo of Tara Lynn

Author: Tara Lynn

Last Updated: January 05, 2023

We purchased and tested a few of the best chew toys for dogs. We’ve done the legwork and chosen 5 of the best dog toys for aggressive chewers so you can narrow down your search and have more time playing with your dog.  We highly recommend Gnawtlers Premium Elk Antlers for Dogs as the best dog chew toy that is currently on the market. Watch the above video and read below the full details of our testing of these popular dog toys.

Choose a charity on Amazon Smile on Spots.com then purchase
via links on this page to donate a portion
of your purchase. Learn more »
Best Overall
Gnawtlers Premium Elk Antlers for Dogs
Gnawtlers Premium Elk Antlers for Dogs Best Overall
$17
on petparentsbrand
9.4/10
  • What we Like
  • Made in USA
  • All Natural, Healthy & Clean Treat
  • specially selected from Grade A premium raw elk antlers
  • Vacuum sealed for your dogs safety
  • Can be soaked in chicken or beef broth for added flavor
  • Options to choose depending on your dog size
  • A perfect doggy gift
  • What we Dislike
  • Sizes will be smaller than expected
  • Won't last that long
Product Details
Material Grade A premium raw elk antlers
Floats

Bounces

Squeaks

Guarantee Contact manufacturer
Our Review

Elk Antlers are the safest chew toy for your pup as they are softer than other chew materials. The Pet Parents Gnawtlers Elk Antlers is recommended for average chewers, they don’t last long on aggressive chewers because they are softer. This Antlers are vacuum sealed for your dogs safety so you can be sure that you’re getting a good-quality chew toy for your dog. The antlers aren’t processed and contain no dyes, so you don’t have to worry about your dog getting exposed to any chemicals or toxins.

Best for Versatile
Kong Extreme Dog Toy Toughest Natural Rubber
Kong Extreme Dog Toy Toughest Natural Rubber Best for Versatile
$15
on kongcompany
8.4/10
  • What we Like
  • Designed for super power chewers
  • Satisfy dogs' instinctual needs and provides mental stimulation
  • Dishwasher safe for easy clean up
  • Can put treats inside for longer playtime
  • Veterinarians and trainers worldwide recommend
  • Comes in 5 sizes S-XXL
  • What we Dislike
  • Not totally indestructible
  • Fine for smaller dogs
  • Has only 2 color options
Product Details
Material Rubber
Floats

Bounces

Squeaks

Guarantee Contact manufacturer
Our Review

KONG designed a variety of toys intended to work for a wide range of play styles, including enhancement toys, fetch toys, chew toys and puzzle toys. This rubber toy’s shape makes it bounce to keep your pup entertained. You can stuff it with treats or peanut butter to keep your little dog occupied day in and day out. It is not totally indestructible but it’s fine for smaller dogs and since the KONG rubber chew toy comes in 5 sizes, it might take a little trial and error to find the perfect fit, especially while your pup’s still growing.

Best Design
Nylabone Power Chew Jumbo Drumstick Chicken Flavor Dog Chew Toy
Nylabone Power Chew Jumbo Drumstick Chicken Flavor Dog Chew Toy Best Design
$23
Review manufacturer chewy
on chewy
7.6/10
  • What we Like
  • Perfect for large dogs above 50 lbs.
  • Help to clean teeth, freshen breath, and promote oral health.
  • Provides hours of chew-time fun
  • Vet-recommended
  • Made in the USA!
  • With turkey or sweet potato flavor
  • What we Dislike
  • Doesn't have that much smell of a turkey
  • Not very much enticing for a dog
  • A bit heavy
  • Recommended for large breeds only
Product Details
Material Nylon
Synthetic Fabric
Floats

Bounces

Squeaks

Guarantee Contact manufacturer
Our Review

Nylabone Flavor Frenzy Turkey-Flavor supports dog dental health. It helps clean teeth as dogs chew. The great thing is that, this chew toy is proudly made in the United States. This turkey chew toy resembles a real drumstick that is sure to keep dogs happy, busy, and satisfied. Nylon chew toy stands up to the most extreme chewing styles. It’s expected to be long lasting for the largest chewers. It’s flavor features irresistible turkey & sweet potato flavor—with zero calories! Our dog has a few of these Nylabones. He cannot get enough of them. Our dog seriously loves this so much. He chews on them for hours and hours. This is definitely our go-to dog toy!

Best for Multiple Dogs
Nylabone Moderate Chew Textured Dog Dental Chew
Nylabone Moderate Chew Textured Dog Dental Chew Best for Multiple Dogs
$8
Review manufacturer chewy
on chewy
7.4/10
  • What we Like
  • Made in USA
  • Extremely durable
  • Cleans teeth, reduces tartar
  • Freshens breath
  • Various shapes, flavors
  • Softer, more flexible feel
  • Original flavor dogs love
  • Great for moderate chewers
  • Available in 3 sizes
  • What we Dislike
  • Not suitable for dogs with pre-existing dental issues
  • Has only 2 color options
Product Details
Material Nylon
Synthetic Fabric
Floats

Bounces

Squeaks

Guarantee Contact manufacturer
Our Review

Nylabone FlexiChew Moderate FlexiChew Dental has the original flavor that dogs love. It has these little teeth on it so that it can potentially clean off a bit of tartar and plaque on your dog’s teeth. If you are on the hunt for just something overall gentle, this toy is softer and give a more flexible feel. It satisfies your dog’s natural urge to chew while it also promotes fresh breath. Great for moderate chewers, the only thing we noticed is that it does come off in small swallowable pieces and is not for intense chewers, small pieces do break off, but fortunately our dog seems to spit most of them out. If your dog tends to swallow the pieces that break off these might not be for you. However, it’s still a product that we would still re-purchase in the future.

Most Durable
Planet Dog Orbee-Tuff Diamond Plate Orange Treat Dispensing Dog
Planet Dog Orbee-Tuff Diamond Plate Orange Treat Dispensing Dog Most Durable
$13
Review manufacturer chewy
on chewy
7/10
  • What we Like
  • Soft on dog's mouth
  • Slightly flexible, easy to grip
  • Minty Scent
  • Recyclable
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Available in Multiple Sizes and Colors
  • Bouncy & Buoyant
  • Durable Treat-Dispensing Toy
  • Made is USA
  • What we Dislike
  • Can be damaged by the most determined chewers
Product Details
Material Rubber
Floats

Bounces

Squeaks

Guarantee Contact manufacturer
Our Review

Planet Dog Orbee-Tuff Diamond Plate Orbee Ball the toughest Orbee-Tuff dog toy yet! Molded from a single piece of rubber with unique diamond textures, this toy is designed with aggressive chewers in mind. They are made from non-toxic BPA- and Phthalate-free materials, this FDA-approved ball beats the socks off of tennis balls for robust dog play. Not too hard, not too squishy soft. It’s hollow, yet durable, which gives a pup’s jaws a good workout. These are fantastic for putting treats inside, and having your dog knock them around. This toy comes in a variety of shapes and flavors with one sure to please your pup. Though, it didn’t last long with our power-chewer who began pulling chunks off within the hour. Due to the hard nature of this toy, it should not be given to breeds with pre-existing dental problems as chewing on it could cause tooth breakage. We do feel it helps with stinky breath but only as long as the dog is chewing on it.

Best Products Best Indestructible Dog Toy
Product Name Best for Rate
Gnawtlers Premium Elk Antlers for Dogs Best Overall 9.4
Kong Extreme Dog Toy Toughest Natural Rubber Best for Versatile 8.4
Nylabone Power Chew Jumbo Drumstick Chicken Flavor Dog Chew Toy Best Design 7.6
Nylabone Moderate Chew Textured Dog Dental Chew Best for Multiple Dogs 7.4
Planet Dog Orbee-Tuff Diamond Plate Orange Treat Dispensing Dog Most Durable 7

How to “Chews” Dog-approved Toys

Dogs are not always picky about what they chew. A pair of designer shoes, the living room sofa, the tv remote control… all are fair game when the chewing instinct strikes. So it makes sense to have some chew toys on hand for your canine companion. But how do you choose?

The fact is no dog toy on earth is truly “indestructible,” but there are many toys that can last much longer than the standard 5-minute snack for aggressive chewers. Because that is how long typical discount store toys last – anywhere from a few minutes to an hour or two. After a trip to the trash can, you’ll be right back where you started.

The best toys are multipurpose. These toys satisfy the chewing instinct, but they’re also fun to play with, both with or without their humans. Dog toys that store treats inside provide mental stimulation while toys that bounce provide a fun game of chase. And if the toy floats, even better for dogs that like water.

The first thing you need to do is determine your dog’s chew and play style. Some dogs are fetchers, others are go for the gusto chewers who love nothing more than to rip their toys to shreds.

Before you start searching for toys to suit your dog’s nature…

Safety First

Safety is of the utmost importance when selecting chew toys for your precious pup. The best and longest lasting chew toys on the market are made with hard rubber. These are the toys that will prove most resistant to the beating an aggressive chewer can dish out. The last thing you want is a cheap toy coming apart and getting lodged either in your dog’s trachea or intestines.

However, if that should happen (and it can, even on the toys labeled “indestructible”), the second feature you should look for is whether the toy is non-toxic. The fact that a chew toy spends so much time in a dog’s mouth makes the toxicity of the toy much more important. And if small bits pass through the intestinal tract, it’s even more important that the pieces are non-toxic.

Another point is whether the toys contains a squeaker. If dislodged from the toy, the squeaker could pose a serious choking threat to your dog.

Rope toys can be extremely dangerous if your dog chews them unattended. We’ve seen $6,000 vet bills to remove these from digestive tracts, and even the chewed-off pieces of rope can bind up a dog’s intestines.

Plush toys are not going to be suitable for your dog’s aggressive chewing. Most dogs enjoy disemboweling anything with stuffing whether it’s a plush toy (especially if there is a squeaker inside), a dog bed, or sometimes, your couch. The stuffing in most plushies is dangerous and can cause health problems for the unlucky dog who ingests it.

 

Think about your dog’s chewing style. If he’s/she’s a very aggressive chewer, you want a toy with a little “give” to it to not risk breaking your pup’s teeth. It can happen when the wrong toy is matched with the wrong dog.

When a toy is damaged, or when it’s been chewed down to a size that can be swallowed, toss it and get a new one. Keep one in a safe place as a back-up.

Quality

You may experience sticker shock when shopping for chew toys for your furry friend, but there’s a reason for the expense. Better quality toys are going to cost more. Period. But on the flip side, better quality toys will last longer, too. You may be new to the struggle- spend $3 on a toy that might last 5 minutes to an hour, and then you have to buy another. And another. Or you could spend $15 on a toy that will last months. Which is the more cost-effective toy?

It makes sense to spend a little more on a toy that will last longer because these are the toys that are also safer. We recommend toys that are manufactured in the US with known standards and quality controls in place.

Durability

The most durable types of dog toys for aggressive chewers on the market are hard rubber, as mentioned earlier. These are the toys that can really take the heat when your dog’s boredom, separation anxiety or teething distress take hold.

Kong, Westpaw, Nylabone, and Playology make a wide variety of hard rubber/nylon styles to suit your dog’s chewing and play styles.